Beautiful Eyebrow Makeup. My Ranking: The Best Brow Mascaras

Eyebrow mascara ranking

Dear readers 🙂

What is worth choosing for your eyebrow makeup? What is a good brow mascara? Today I will help you find the answers to these questions. I have rounded up the best eyebrow mascaras and created a beauty ranking, which I hope will help you discover what is the best brow mascara. Are you curious which product won? Is it a brow mascara from Boots, or some other store? Check it out, surely my ranking of the best brow mascaras can pleasantly surprise you!

Eyebrow-thickening mascara – beautiful makeup, defined eyebrows

Why are we interested in a good brow mascara? Because it is a unique product that ensures we can emphasize the color and shape of our eyebrows, give them a thicker look and add definition very quickly, and without much effort. Eyebrow mascara is easy to use, and a well-chosen one can make the eyebrows not only more defined, but also perfectly shaped, and the whole makeup is precise and flawless.  The coolest thing about brow mascara is that we don’t need to be skilled in makeup at all to get a great result. That’s why brow mascara is one of the most popular and frequently chosen cosmetics

Eyebrow mascara ranking

Which brow mascara is worth buying? If you are interested in the best eyebrow mascara, check out the following ranking of the best mascaras and decide which one deserves to find its place in your makeup bag. My ranking of the best brow mascaras was based on reviews, prices, quality, and the makeup effects each brow mascara gives. The available shades also mattered to me: does the brand have black brow mascara? Can you find a nice eyebrow mascara for blonde hair? Check it out for yourselves! Here’s my ranking of the best eyebrow mascaras, enjoy. 

NANOBROW SHAPE MASCARA 

best eyebrow mascara
  • Size: 7 ml
    What is the best eyebrow mascara? There is a huge possibility that you will love Nanobrow Shape Mascara as much as I did. This mascara gave me the most beautiful eyebrows ever! The makeup effects are simply THE BEST, the size, the durability, the shades, and that brilliant spoolie – these are the main advantages of Nanobrow brow mascara! You can find both suitable shades for black and blonde hair.
  • Makeup effects
    I really like the makeup effects this mascara gives. The brush is very precise and allows you to gradually intensify the makeup effect, so with this eyebrow mascara, you can create a delicate effect for everyday wear but also bold evening makeup and well-defined eyebrows. The great thing is that even after several coats your eyebrows will look perfect because Nanobrow Shape Mascara is clump-free and does not leave any residue. 
  • Reviews
    I am very happy to see that Nanobrow’s brow mascara is getting excellent reviews and is praised in so many countries. As you can see, I am not alone in my admiration for this mascara. It’s a frequently recommended brow mascara! And look at its large size! BEAUTIFUL! 
  • Price
    The price of Nanobrow mascara is very affordable! The nice thing is that we can get a good quality product without overpaying! <3

LANCOME SOURCILS STYLER BROW MASCARA

  • Size: 6.5 ml
    Large size, pretty good makeup effects, and decent durability placed this brow mascara high in my ranking. I must admit that with its classic brush, this is a really good product. 
  • Makeup effects
    Quite a nice aesthetic and neat brow makeup (expect more styled brows than a thicker brow look) and nice carefully selected shades make this eyebrow mascara makeup effects very decent.  It is also quite long-wear, so you can be sure that it will last on your eyebrows all day.
  • Reviews
    For a long time, this was my favorite eyebrow mascara, which quite often appeared in my makeup bag… unfortunately, it also ruined my budget, and I truly dislike overpaying for cosmetics. I noticed that it is a recommended brow mascara among many women. Is it worth buying it though? I leave the decision to you, of course.
  • Price
    Unfortunately… we pay not only for the product, but I guess also for the brand, so the price of this eyebrow mascara is TOO high. 

CLINIQUE JUST BROW MASCARA

  • Size: 2 ml
    This is an unusual eyebrow mascara, described as a mousse for styling eyebrows. It adds color and tames the eyebrows quite well, adding extra definition. The formula is waterproof, sweat and moisture-resistant, and ophthalmologically tested.
  • Makeup effects
    It helps to control the shape of the arches and tames the brows, giving them a nice shape. In addition, it optically increases the volume. It contains crystalline mineral wax, which smooths and softens the brows. This brow mascara adds a healthy shine, creating a special protective layer. You gotta like this specific effect in brow makeup…. as is not for everyone. 
  • Reviews
    This is indeed a waterproof eyebrow mascara. However, many users admit that although it does not smudge and does not wear off the brows, after a  while, it can become slightly flaky. I really like its brush; even though it’s classic and cone-shaped, it has very dense bristles so it works very precisely without leaving clumps.
  • Price
    Yes, you see it right: this eyebrow mascara comes in such a small size at a high price. Is the purchase of this eyebrow mascara worth it though? I think that if you have extremely sensitive skin, this may be the only option, but if it’s not that bad… then unfortunately it’s not worth its staggering price. You can possibly check if this brow mascara is on special offer in Sephora – then you can save a little.

BENEFIT GIMME BROW MASCARA

  • Size: 3 g
    The size of this brow mascara may not be the best, and the brush a bit old-school, but the shades are great. The manufacturer labels them as neutral, warm, and cool shades so you can match them to your skin tone.  There will be an eyebrow mascara for blondes, as well as for ladies with dark eyes.
  • Makeup effects
    This brow mascara gives a very strong effect of ultimately defined eyebrows, and this is due to the classic brush and thanks to the special fibers in the formula of this mascara. The fibers in the mascara settle on brow hairs so the eyebrows appear thicker and more defined. However, this look is a little too strong, and I don’t know how to use a brush with such a wide spacing of bristles. Perhaps it works well on thicker eyebrows. 
  • Reviews
    This brow mascara has been gaining popularity over the years and today it is one of the most readily commented on. As far as I can see, this brow mascara has different opinions, voices are divided.  This eyebrow mascara can create exceptionally strong evening makeup that looks really nice, but unfortunately for daytime makeup, it does not suit everyone.
  • Price
    Apparently, among many makeup fans, this eyebrow mascara is considered iconic. And I guess that’s the only reason why it’s still on top because neither its price nor its rather small size is encouraging. Sorry: in my case it is not the best eyebrow mascara. 

URBAN DECAY BROW MASCARA ENDOWED

  • Size: 1.8 ml
    This mascara found its place in my ranking of the best brow mascaras as its users praise it for its high durability and interesting feature: it’s a double-sided mascara, which has a tinted mascara on one end and a transparent brow gel on the other. I guess the gel is supposed to style the brows and fix them, but it smudges the pigment on the skin… Perhaps I haven’t mastered the art of using this brow mascara.
  • Makeup effects
    Dear readers! Here is a brow mascara that can give you ultimately thick eyebrows. The brows almost look overdrawn and this effect is not everyone’s cup of tea. I, unfortunately, had to brush it out of my eyebrows as the effect was too strong for my liking.
  • Reviews
    Many users speak positively about this brow mascara but praise especially the transparent option that fixes the brows. Perhaps because the tinted version gives way too strong an effect. Definitely more suitable for the evening… 
  • Price
    Unfortunately, this eyebrow mascara comes at a high price for a small size. It’s tiny!

Eyebrow mascara – how to use it?

I think the most brilliant thing about eyebrow mascara is its super easy use: simply open the mascara and brush it through your brow using the wand. It is often the case that one coat of brow mascara is enough to create beautiful daytime makeup, but if you need a more intense effect you can apply an extra coat. Wait until it dries and add some more mascara. A good brow mascara should be clump-free and leave no residue, even if you feel like applying several coats, it should do its job perfectly.  In my ranking of the best mascaras, the highest-rated ones are precisely those eyebrow mascaras that ensure the greatest precision and let you build up the coverage.

Transparent eyebrow mascara – does it make sense?

I noticed you often ask about transparent eyebrow mascara… Is it better than the tinted version? I have to tell you that in my opinion, transparent brow mascara does not make sense at all. This is because brow mascara, by definition, is supposed not only to style but, above all, give brows a thicker look and add extra definition. The transparent version simply doesn’t work this way so if you are looking for a clear eyebrow mascara, choose a brow gel, which has a different formula than the mascara and fixes and styles the brows perfectly. 

Waterproof eyebrow mascara – is it worth choosing? 

Eyebrow mascara should be long-wear, but does it have to be waterproof right away? I think that you do not need such an intense action. A waterproof formula makes it very difficult to wash off the eyebrows when removing makeup. Sometimes you have to rub the skin hard which can significantly weaken the condition of your eyebrows. I would rather bet on a long-wear eyebrow mascara that works well, washes off easily, and does not damage brow hairs. 

Let me know which brow mascara is the best in your opinion and if you found your favorite in my best brow mascara ranking! Hugs!

Give a Comment